Jin (osprey_archer) wrote,
Jin
osprey_archer

Caldecott Monday: Noah's Ark

We've reached another Caldecott book that I'm familiar with from childhood! (And in fact we'll run into quite a few of them for the next twenty years of Caldecott books or so.) My parents actually owned Peter Spier's Noah's Ark, so I was quite familiar with it, although I must say it never was a favorite: the ark gets awfully dirty from having so many animals in it, which is only reasonable, but I thought all the piles of dung were gross.

I also found the Noah's ark story itself a bit upsetting - particularly the bit at the beginning where alllll the animals are gathering around the ark, but Noah's only letting them on two by two so you've got, say, a bunch of elephants standing around, dolefully waiting to drown. Why do the elephants deserve to drown because humans were horrible? It seems so unfair.

It occurs to me, rather gloomily, that at this point we might see the Noah's ark story as something like a prophecy: the elephants etc. still don't deserve to suffer, but human activity is slowly killing them off anyway - not with a literal flood, but from poachers servicing the rising tide of human greed. It is often the innocents who suffer most.

This is rather gloomy, especially considering the book itself is about as cheery as a retelling of Noah's ark can be. There are all sorts of fun animal vignettes (the elephant who doesn't fit out of the ark; the flood of rabbits coming out, because the two beginning rabbits have bred a four score and seven baby bunnies), all of which is very cute.

This entry was originally posted at http://osprey-archer.dreamwidth.org/578853.html. Please comment there using OpenID.
Tags: books, caldecott books, elephants, nature, picture books
Subscribe

  • Caldecott Monday: Ox-Cart Man

    Alas, alas - my library did not get me the next Caldecott book in time for my Monday read! WHATEVER SHALL I DO? Well, fortuitously, next week's book…

  • Book Review: Touring America by Automobile in the 1920s

    If, like me, you read the title Touring America by Automobile in the 1920s and all but swoon with joy - and swoon again when you realize that this…

  • Wednesday Reading Meme

    What I’ve Just Finished Reading Mockingjay. D: D: D: TEARS FOREVER. I also finished Miss Read’s Miss Clare Remembers, which I enjoyed very much…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

  • 4 comments